NPR for Northern Colorado
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
Available On Air Stations

The Big Apple's Mayor Makes A Very Scary Video

I didn't know what to make of this when I saw it. I live in Manhattan, in a city where people bike, take buses, subways, trains, live and work in towers where they share elevators, share water, share electricity. I thought my town is setting the example for energy-efficient, communal living. And then, the guy who runs the place, Mayor Michael Bloomberg, releases a study — including (see below) a shocking video that says, you think New York is great on energy? You think that? Well, check thisout...

The mayor has an Office of Long Term Planning and Sustainability (that includes Jonathan Dickinson and Andrea Tenorio and staff) and they decided to measure how much carbon dioxide escapes into the New York air. To make the data more visual, they assumed every day in New York is a nice day, where the temperature is 59 degrees Fahrenheit, and where, under standard pressure, a ton of CO 2 gas would fill a lovely blue bubble 33 feet across like the ones you see down there, rising from the traffic.

Bubbles on street level
/ YouTube

Then they asked, "if we took all the CO 2 coming from vehicles, buildings, power plants across the city and gathered them in a clump, at one spot right next the Empire State Building, how much CO 2 is emitted in a single hour? This is what they found.

One Hour Of NYC's Carbon Dioxide Emissions
/ YouTube

That's one hour. How about a day? How much CO 2 does New York City produce in a day?

One Day Of New York City'€™s Carbon Dioxide Emissions
/ YouTube

This isn't looking so good, especially if you believe accumulating greenhouse gases may increase the ferocity of storms coming in off the Atlantic. So let's take a deep breath and ask how much CO 2 does New York City create in a year?

One Year Of NYC's Carbon Dioxide Emissions
/ YouTube

"Oy," as some New Yorkers like to say. This is a whole lot of gas, several tons per person. This is not what I was expecting.

One Year'€™s Emissions From Above
/ YouTube

So what are we to think? This graphic is just a snapshot of New York. It says nothing about how the city compares to Ft. Worth, Texas, or Bar Harbor, Maine, or Shanghai. Just because it looks horrible, doesn't mean, it ishorrible, though these images leave me with the unmistakable sense that New York is being strangled under a mountain of its own waste.

Is it? (And why, by the way, is the Mayor's staff creating pictures like this? He wrote the forward to their report, so he wants us to see these pictures.What's up with that?)

For some answers, I called up a climate scientist who lives and works in my neighborhood, Pushker Kharecha of Columbia University's Earth Institute. He, like me, wakes up every day to what are often blue skies. I assume he takes deep breaths. I asked him, "Is this as bad as it looks?" And he said. "It's grim, yes," but there are, he thinks, a few silver linings.

Like what? I asked.

For one thing, he says, as I suspected, New York isn't as bad as other places. If you compare cities to suburbs and rural areas, cities are often more energy efficient. People who live in detached houses, who drive everywhere, whose power comes from coal and gas, often have much higher CO 2 emissions per capita.

Yes, New York's Dirty, But Check The Suburbs...

A recent study compared 12 large (and mostly rich) cities around the world with the average emissions of their respective countries and the cities did nicely. New York City's per capita emissions are about a third the U.S. average.

So we're dirty, but we're three times more efficient than typical Americans. The same goes for residents of Toronto and Barcelona, they're three times better than their countrymen. Tokyo, London and Seoul are about twice as efficient.

Cities, even rich ones, perform differently. In this list of 12, starting with the dirtiest, New York comes in fifth. These are greenhouse gas emissions per person (What's with Washington?)

  • Washington, D.C., U.S. — 19.7 tons of CO2 equivalent
  • Glasgow, UK — 8.4 tons
  • Toronto, Canada — 8.2 tons
  • Shanghai, China — 8.1 tons
  • New York City, U.S. — 7.1 tons
  • Beijing, China — 6.9 tons
  • London, U.K. — 6.2 tons
  • Tokyo, Japan — 4.8 tons
  • Seoul, South Korea — 3.8 tons
  • Barcelona, Spain — 3.4 tons
  • Rio de Janeiro, Brazil — 2.3 tons
  • Sao Paulo, Brazil — 1.5 tons
  • Cities differ because some have lots of factories, some don't. Some have more refrigerators, air conditioners, fancy appliances than others. Some have more modern, tighter buildings, more office towers, more public transit. (Washington is warmer, often stifling, is that why it's such an emitter? Can we blame air conditioning?) But whatever the differences, that pile of bubbles still gets to me.

    NYC Carbon Emissions
    / YouTube

    If whenever people gather — and that's what we do, we gather — we produce this much waste or worse, what am I to think? Mayor Bloomberg's video images feel like a dark prophecy, a prediction of doom.

    "Grim," says Pushker Kharecha, but doom? Nah. He says there are two challenges here: we must eventually wean ourselves from coal, gas and carbon-rich fuels, but in the meantime, we can cut down on the bubble-making by redesigning cars, putting more people in buses, subways, creating tighter, ever-more-efficient buildings, adjusting our values; those are real, achievable goals."Combating climate change is one of the great challenges of our age," Mayor Bloomberg says in his forward. His video was meant to warn us, not to scare us.

    Well, here it is. Take a look, and you decide. Are you scared or are you pumped?

    Me? I'm a little bit of both.

    Copyright 2020 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

    Robert Krulwich works on radio, podcasts, video, the blogosphere. He has been called "the most inventive network reporter in television" by TV Guide.
    Related Content
    • In the long run, geoengineering — tinkering with air, oceans, the skies — will help us survive on a changing planet. More and more eminent scientists agree that if the human race survives, the engineers will get smarter, the tools will get better, and one day we will control the climate. But should we?
    • A boy leaves his house, steps onto the street and is assaulted by a crush of noises; he seems to be autistic, can't focus, can't sort the sounds. But somebody he bumps into (literally) sees what's wrong.
    • The world's first essayist, Michel Montaigne, was out riding one day when he got slammed from the rear, was thrown from his horse, crashed to the ground and for a brief time was, as he puts it, "dead." He described exactly what it felt like. Here's what he learned.
    • Four million people watched this video filmed beneath the surface of a frozen lake. What really happened on that cold day in Finland can now be revealed, although clever viewers may have already figured out the tricks.