In German Coal Country, This Former Socialist Model City Has Shrunk In Half

Nov 7, 2019
Originally published on November 7, 2019 5:09 pm

It was two years after the Berlin Wall had fallen when Karsten Hilse realized the people in his town had changed. It came to him in a blast of hot, white light.

"It was the first time that a firebomb was thrown at me," Hilse remembers. "Things like that didn't happen in the GDR."

Hilse was a young police officer in his hometown of Hoyerswerda, in the former East Germany, also known as the German Democratic Republic or GDR. In 1991, a year after Germany reunified, rioters in the city targeted immigrants from countries such as Vietnam and Mozambique, accusing them of taking jobs away from Germans. Hilse, dressed in riot gear to fend off the attackers, suddenly didn't recognize Hoyerswerda, a city where, just a few years prior, work was plentiful and most people made the same salary.

"If you don't have enough — if you've lost your job, and when everything that you'd hoped and wished would happen with reunification fails to materialize ... and you all of a sudden have all of this freedom, but not enough money to actually use it, that's really very frustrating," says Hilse, now 54 and a member of German parliament. "That makes it so that people are looking for someone to blame."

As Germany celebrates the 30th anniversary of the fall of the Berlin Wall this week — and the end of a divided state that followed — cities in the former east such as Hoyerswerda are still struggling to thrive, evidence that in a country united for nearly three decades, divisions between east and west still exist.

"True socialist new city"

For decades, Hoyerswerda's coal mines and massive power plant, Schwarze Pumpe (literally "black pump"), were among the industrial and economic engines of East Germany.

"This large power plant, this gas separation plant, the world's largest, needed an unending supply of workers," says Kirstin Zinke, director of the Saxon Museum of Industry at Knappenrode, outside Hoyerswerda.

In the late 1950s, architects were brought in to plan a socialist utopia based around the coal industry, including large state housing for workers and green spaces for their families.

"This new town was meant to be a true socialist new city that stripped away the trauma of two World Wars that affected everyone in the '50s. It was supposed to imagine this truly socialist and just future society."

Kirstin Zinke stands in front of the Knappenrode museum, where she is the director.
Rob Schmitz / NPR

In November 1989, the Berlin Wall fell, and soon after so did the communist state, a satellite of the Soviet Union. The rapid switch to capitalism changed the celebrated status of the worker, according to the museum director.

"It was exactly this person, who was so idealized until 1990, who was always placed on a pedestal, who from one day to the next became the pariah of the nation," Zinke says of the figure of the laborer.

Many here long for the times before reunification because they were doing a lot better. - Madlen Krenz, a laid-off coal mine employee who runs a food bank

Then the city's population plummeted. What was a communist industrial hub of nearly 70,000 people in 1987 has now lost over half its population, as residents have looked for jobs elsewhere. Today it has fewer than 33,000 people, according to federal statistics. The anthropologist Felix Ringel has called it "Germany's fastest-shrinking city."

Some of those who remain convey some nostalgia about the notorious former system. Madlen Krenz, 52, lost her job in one of the many rounds of layoffs at the former state coal mining company, Schwarze Pumpe. "Many here long for the times before reunification because they were doing a lot better," she says. "You didn't have to consider anything — you really just lived your life on a sedated path. Nowadays you have to worry about your job. You're scared that you could become sick for a long period of time. It wasn't like that in the GDR."

After years of trying to find work, Krenz became the director of a local food bank. For a small entrance fee, people who make less than 1,000 euros ($1,105) a month stock up on produce, meat and baked goods.

"No matter how you look at it, the money isn't enough, so I have to come here," says 38-year-old Roland Scholz, one of an estimated 600 people who depend on the food bank.

Scholz is raising four children here, and he worries about their future. He says crystal meth is a big problem in the city, and his kids don't have much to do. "When I was a kid, I played outside all day with my friends until the church bell rang and I had to come home," he remembers. "In Hoyerswerda [nowadays], you hope and pray your kids come back unharmed."

That's why social worker Irena Kerber organizes soccer matches for at-risk teens. "Some of these kids have some idea for what they'd like to do with their lives, but most just sit in front of the computer or the TV," says Kerber, as she plays goalkeeper in a pickup game. "For most, this is the one thing that they have in terms of some sort of playground activity."

But the future isn't totally bleak for these children, according to Mirko Kolodziej, a local journalist for the Hoyerswerdaer Tageblatt newspaper. The city's jobless rate is at a 30-year low of 6.6%, although that is about twice the national rate. Local employment options include a hospital and a range of medium-size companies. Kolodziej says many fellow citizens are now focused on urban gardening and activities for young people.

Mirko Koloziedj, reporter for the Hoyerswerdaer Tageblatt newspaper, stands among buildings constructed during the city's boom in the 1960s.
Rob Schmitz / NPR
You can be happy in a shrinking city. - Mirko Kolodziej, journalist

"We are kind of an example that you can be happy in a shrinking city. We started a lot of cultural projects here and community work and a lot of different projects to try and bring people together," he says.

Phasing out coal

But for Jens Dubrau, head of the local coal miners' union, more needs to be done for Hoyerswerda. "Our concerns are essentially the same ones we had after unification in the '90s: that jobs will disappear," says Dubrau. "The federal government has already decided that Germany is finished burning coal. But they haven't offered any alternatives."

Dubrau stands underneath the large cooling towers of Schwarze Pumpe, the facility around which communist-era Hoyerswerda was built. Germany's government decided earlier this year that the country will stop burning coal by 2038. It has plans for alternative energy sources such as gas, wind, solar and hydropower but critics in coal country say this won't be enough.

The cut-off date also worries Hilse, who represents Hoyerswerda in German parliament in Berlin. "It's a catastrophe," he says.

Hilse questions the science behind cutting out coal use, a high carbon emitter that contributes to climate change. He is a member of the Alternative for Germany, or AfD, a political party criticized for hosting climate change deniers and anti-immigrant sentiments. The far-right party's popularity has surged in states such as Saxony, where Hoyerswerda is located.

Hilse shrugs off the criticism to focus on what he says is a crucial energy policy mistake. The plan to shut Germany's nuclear and coal power plants, he argues, will leave the country without enough electricity and will shed many jobs. He estimates it will lead to 25,000 lost jobs in Germany's coal industry, many of them in Hoyerswerda.

That, he says, will hurt a city that was supposed to be built for the well-being of its workers.

Austin Davis contributed to this story.

Copyright 2019 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

MARY LOUISE KELLY, HOST:

It has been 30 years since the fall of the Berlin Wall. Now, much has changed since November 1991. And this week, NPR's Rob Schmitz is bringing us stories about the changes that have happened since East and West Germany became one again. Today, Rob takes us to a city that was the industrial center of the former east to see how the city has changed.

ROB SCHMITZ, BYLINE: November 9, 1989.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

PETER JENNINGS: I'm Peter Jennings in New York. Just a short while ago, astonishing news from East Germany, where the East German authorities have said, in essence, that the Berlin Wall doesn't mean anything anymore.

SCHMITZ: A suddenly meaningless border led to a meaningless state of communist East Germany.

(CHEERING)

SCHMITZ: And as crowds in Berlin cheered, people in the Eastern German city of Hoyerswerda was suddenly unsure of who they were, says Kirstin Zinke, director of the Knappenrode energy museum.

KIRSTIN ZINKE: (Through interpreter) This town was meant to be a true socialist city. It was supposed to imagine a just future society.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

UNIDENTIFIED PERSON: (Speaking German).

SCHMITZ: A propaganda video from 1950s East Germany extols the benefits of life under communism, and Hoyerswerda had it all. Established as a utopia for workers, its coal mining and power plant where the economic and industrial engines of the former East.

ZINKE: (Through interpreter) The housing complexes were built in such a way as if to say people need good apartments large apartments. Social welfare was thought about and financed in the way that they built schools and daycares in the surroundings.

SCHMITZ: But then the Berlin Wall fell. Capitalism replaced communism. And the status of the model of workers of Hoyerswerda plummeted.

ZINKE: (Through interpreter) the entire mining industry caved in. There was a ton of unemployment. It was really difficult for a lot of people.

SCHMITZ: Madlen Krenz lost her job with a coal mining company, so did thousands of others. Today, Hoyerswerda has around half the population it had three decades ago.

MADLEN KRENZ: (Through interpreter) Many here long for the times before reunification because they were doing a lot better. You didn't have to consider anything. You really just live your life on a sedated path. Nowadays, you have to worry about your job. You're scared that you could become sick for a long period of time. It wasn't like before.

SCHMITZ: After years of trying to find work, Krenz became the director of this local food bank. For a small entrance fee, people who make less than a thousand euros a month stock up on produce, meat and baked goods. Thirty-eight-year-old Roland Scholz is one of hundreds who depend on the food bank to get by.

ROLAND SCHOLZ: (Through interpreter) No matter how you look at it, the money isn't enough. So I have to come here.

SCHMITZ: Scholz is raising four children here, and he worries about their future. He says crystal meth is a big problem. The kids don't have much to do.

(SOUNDBITE OF KIDS PLAYING)

SCHMITZ: And that's why social worker Irena Kerber organizes soccer matches for at-risk youth.

IRENA KERBER: (Through interpreter) Some of these kids have some idea for what they'd like to do with their lives, but most just sit in front of the computer or the TV. For most, this is the one thing that they have in terms of some sort of playground activity.

SCHMITZ: The future is not totally bleak for these kids. Employers in town include a hospital and a range of medium-sized companies. But for Jens Dubrau, head of the coal miners' union, more needs to be done for Hoyerswerda.

JENS DUBRAU: (Through interpreter) Our concerns are essentially the same ones we had after unification in the '90s - that jobs will disappear. The federal government has already decided that Germany is finished burning coal, but they haven't offered any alternatives.

SCHMITZ: Dubrau says the average age of those left in the city hovers around 55 years old.

DUBRAU: (Through interpreter) These are not the workers we need for the future. That's a big problem. We're afraid we're on our way to becoming a totally deindustrialized area with nothing left here at the end of it all but poverty.

SCHMITZ: And for those that remain, memories of what life was like decades ago, when good jobs were plentiful.

Rob Schmitz, NPR News, Hoyerswerda, Germany. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.