More Than 400 Have Called Pennsylvania's Hotline Since Clergy Sex Abuse Report

Aug 21, 2018
Originally published on August 21, 2018 9:04 am

Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro was wrapping up his livestreamed address in Harrisburg last week, on the release of a bombshell grand jury report cataloging how the Catholic Church covered up the abuse of more than 1,000 minors by some 300 priests over 70 years, when he made an appeal: We want more survivors to report.

"If you are listening to this news conference, and you know of sexual abuse being committed by a priest or a member of clergy against yourself, or anyone else, please call us," Shapiro implored viewers.

Since then, according to Pennsylvania officials, a cascade of more than 400 calls has rolled in to the clergy-abuse hotline.

The attorney general's office has been scrambling to keep up, pulling in specially trained investigators from other departments to handle the deluge, according to Joe Grace, a spokesman for Shapiro.

"We've deployed agents from our child predator section and brought them over to answer and respond to these calls that are coming in to the hotline," said Grace, noting that the surge in calls is the largest officials have seen since the hotline was launched two years ago.

The nearly 900-page searing grand jury report has not just reawakened the stories of people from Pennsylvania. In San Francisco, Melanie Sakoda with the Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests said the report produced a measurable uptick in call volume to the group's national hotline.

"Were we prepared for it? No," Sakoda said. "We've been caught a little bit short-handed."

Usually, the group's hotline receives a handful of calls a day. Shortly after the grand jury report, Sakoda was trying to respond to some 22 calls — and that was just the morning's volume.

Sakoda said that some of the callers are concerned Catholics looking for ways to help. Others are survivors or family members of survivors of sexual assault who have been shaken by some of the priests' names in the report.

"My abuser's on the list, you know, what should I do? Or they're saying, 'My abuser isn't on the list, what should I do?' " Sakoda said.

For many of the callers, justice in Pennsylvania is out of reach.

Laws in Pennsylvania bar anyone over the age of 30 from filing a civil lawsuit against a child sex abuser. And a criminal case involving child sex abuse must be started before the victim is 50 years old.

According to University of Pennsylvania professor Marci Hamilton, those are some of the most outdated child-abuse laws in the country. Her advocacy group called Child USA has found that the average age of someone coming forward to report child abuse is 52.

"For the state of Pennsylvania to be stuck on an age limit on being able to press charges is unusual at this point and puts them definitely in the minority," Hamilton said.

Sometimes, the problem has nothing to do with an old abuse case being legally expired. Some abusers have died, or victims are unable to testify, making it impossible for prosecutors to assemble a criminal case.

Yet for some of those picking up the phone, a remedy in the court system is not the end goal. Hamilton said talking to someone about early childhood abuse can be cathartic and can help a survivor advance beyond it. But she said the experience of talking about it with a stranger can cut the other way, too.

"Well now they have to make a decision, 'Do I tell my wife? Do I tell my children? Do I now talk to the media like the other survivors are doing?' " Hamilton said.

State investigators, Hamilton said, may be limited in their ability to assist someone in processing the full depth of this kind of trauma.

"So it is a very difficult thing to decide to do. And it can be extremely stressful, and it can bring on some of the demons that have visited them because of the abuse," she said.

Hamilton's research has shown that about a third of abused minors speak up about their attacks as kids, a third disclose the abuse as adults, and the remainder remain silent about what happened, figuring it to be the fastest way to move on.

"We have many victims that sit in the wings and that don't say anything," Hamilton said.

Joe Grace, with the Pennsylvania attorney general's office, said he hopes many of those whose cases remain unknown will step forward. After all, cases generated from the 2-year-old clergy-abuse hotline helped to shape the nearly 900 pages of grand jury findings. And investigators are listening to all the new calls of horrific abuse and committing to vetting each one and pursuing them as far as the law will allow.

"They're recording facts," Grace said of the state agents on the other side of the phone calls. "And then decisions will be made – and are being made – to investigate further where it is appropriate."

Meanwhile, supporters of child abuse victims are lobbying state lawmakers to pass new legislation in Pennsylvania that would allow victims more time to seek justice.

Although it is a sweeping document, Hamilton described the enormous grand jury report as an "outline of abuse," far from a comprehensive probe into each incident.

"It's not what you get when you are actually capable of getting into the legal justice system," she said.

Copyright 2018 WHYY. To see more, visit WHYY.

DAVID GREENE, HOST:

The phone lines at the state attorney general's office in Pennsylvania have not stopped ringing. Hotline numbers have surged with calls in the aftermath of a scathing grand jury report which describes decades of child sex abuse and a massive cover-up by the Catholic Church. As Bobby Allyn of member station WHYY reports, officials are scrambling to keep up with hundreds of new tips that are coming through on a clergy abuse hotline.

BOBBY ALLYN, BYLINE: Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro was wrapping up his live-streamed address in Harrisburg last week. It was on the release of a grand jury report detailing how more than 300 Pennsylvania priests abused over a thousand victims in the Catholic Church since the 1940s. And he made a call-out.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

JOSH SHAPIRO: If you are listening to this news conference and you know of sexual abuse being committed by a priest or a member of clergy against yourself or anyone else, please call us.

ALLYN: More than 400 calls have come in in the weeks since the report was made public. Joe Grace is a spokesman for Shapiro. He says state officials are pulling investigators from other departments to handle the deluge.

JOE GRACE: We've deployed agents from our child predator section and brought them over to answer and respond to these calls that are coming into the hotline.

ALLYN: Melanie Sakoda with the Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests says the group's own national hotline has also seen a surge in calls since the report was released.

MELANIE SAKODA: Were we prepared for it? No. We have been caught a little bit short-handed.

ALLYN: Sakoda says some are concerned Catholics looking for ways to help. Others are survivors of sexual assault who have questions.

SAKODA: My abuser's on the list. You know, what should I do? Or, they're saying my abuser isn't on the list. What should I do?

ALLYN: Laws in Pennsylvania bar anyone over the age of 30 from filing a civil lawsuit against a child sex abuser. And a criminal case involving child sex abuse must be started before the victim is 50 years old. According to University of Pennsylvania law professor Marci Hamilton, those are some of the most outdated child abuse laws in the country. Her advocacy group called Child USA has found that the average age of someone coming forward with child abuse is 52.

MARCI HAMILTON: For the state of Pennsylvania to be stuck on an age limit on being able to press charges is unusual at this point and puts them definitely in the minority.

ALLYN: But for some of those calling in, justice in the court system is not the only end goal. Hamilton says talking to someone about the abuse can be cathartic and can help a survivor move on. But she says the experience can cut the other way, too.

HAMILTON: Well, now they have to make a decision. Do I tell my wife? Do I tell my children? Do I now talk to the media like the other survivors are doing?

ALLYN: State investigators, Hamilton says, may be limited in their ability to help someone process these kinds of traumatic questions.

HAMILTON: So it is a very difficult thing to decide to do. And it can be extremely stressful. And it can bring on some of the demons that have visited them because of the abuse.

ALLYN: Joe Grace with the Pennsylvania attorney general's office says cases generated from the 2-year-old clergy abuse hotline helped shape the nearly 900 pages of grand jury findings. And investigators are listening to all the new calls of horrific abuse.

GRACE: They're recording facts. And then decisions will be made and are being made to investigate further where it is appropriate.

ALLYN: Meanwhile, supporters of child abuse victims are lobbying state lawmakers to pass new legislation in Pennsylvania that would allow victims more time to seek justice.

Bobby Allyn, NPR News, Philadelphia.

(SOUNDBITE OF RHIANNON BANNENBERG'S "TO FINALLY BE SEEN") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.