Organ Transplants Down As Stay-At-Home Rules Reduce Fatal Traffic Collisions
On Day 2 of the San Francisco Bay Area's stay-at-home orders in March, Nohemi Jimenez got into her car in San Pablo, Calif., waved goodbye to her 3-year-old son and drove to her regular Wednesday dialysis appointment.
The roads were deserted. No traffic. Jimenez says it is hard to admit what she thought next: No traffic meant no car crashes. And that meant she'd be on the waiting list for a kidney transplant even longer.
"I don't want to be mean, but I was like, 'Oh, my God. Nobody's going to die,'" she says. "I'm not going to get my transplant."
Jimenez, who is now 30 years old, was 20 and pregnant with her first child when doctors discovered she had been born with only one kidney, and that lone kidney was failing. By age 29, doctors told her she needed a new one. It was strange and scary, she says, waiting for someone to die so she could live.
"You're just thinking about it," she says. "It's sitting in your mind. It just can never leave you alone."
Deaths from motor vehicle crashes and fatal injuries are the biggest source of organs for transplant, accounting for 33% of donations, according to the United Network for Organ Sharing, which manages the nation's organ transplant system.
But ever since the coronavirus forced Californians indoors, those accidents have declined. Traffic collisions and fatalities in the state dropped by half in the first three weeks of shelter-in-place restrictions, according to a study by the University of California, Davis. Drowning deaths dropped 80% in California, according to data compiled by the nonprofit .
In April, organ procurement organizations typically see a surge in donations related to outdoor, spring break-related activities and travel, but not this year.
From March 8 to April 11, the number of organ donors who died in traffic collisions was down 23% nationwide compared with the same period last year, while donors who died in all other types of accidents were down 21%, according to data from UNOS.
"Spring break accidents are almost nonexistent because there's no spring break — beach accidents, motorcycle accidents, hunting accidents," says Janice Whaley, CEO of , which manages organ donations for Northern California and Nevada.
Doctors say they've also noticed a decline in emergency room visits overall, not just for accidents, and this may also be limiting the supply of donor organs.
"Where are all the people with heart attacks? Where are all the people with strokes?" says George Rutherford, a professor and infectious disease physician at the University of California, San Francisco. "Are those patients staying away from the ERs for fear of COVID? Clearly, the census is way down in ERs."
At Kaiser Permanente medical centers in Northern California, where 4.4 million patients get care, weekly hospital admissions for heart attacks have dropped almost 50% since the region's first COVID-19 death was reported in early March.
Strokes and heart attacks are the second and third most common sources of organ donations, accounting for 27% and 20% of organs, respectively, according to UNOS.
When people die from a stroke or heart attack at home instead of a hospital, their organs cannot be used for transplant because of lost blood flow. Most organ donations occur after a person suffers a near-fatal event and lifesaving measures do not work. For organs to be viable, people must die or be declared brain-dead while on a ventilator, so blood keeps pumping to the heart, lungs, liver and kidneys.
COVID preparations slow transplant pipeline
A range of other logistical complications have made transplants difficult during the coronavirus pandemic. Hospitals have had to scale back surgeries of all kinds to preserve scarce supplies of personal protective equipment and ventilators. And many haven't had the bandwidth to manage the delicate timing and complexity of organ donation, recovery, transportation and transplantation.
Transplant surgeries across the country plummeted 52% from March 8 to April 11, according to UNOS data.
"There are a lot of things that have to happen perfectly, and now we're in an imperfect situation where we're trying to deal with so many other things," Whaley says.
Earlier in the pandemic, as medical centers braced for a wave of COVID-19 patients, they wanted to free up as many ventilators as possible. In addition to donors needing to die on ventilators to keep their organs viable, doctors often keep them on ventilators for two or three days while transplant teams and recipients are lined up. Then the recipients need to be on ventilators during surgery.
"People were very antsy about having non-COVID-19 patients on ventilators, taking up space," Whaley says. "They wanted to make sure they were ready for that next patient."
Many COVID patients who died had previously signed up to have their organs donated for transplantation upon death; but those organs were declined,out of concern that recipients could become infected, Whaley says.
Testing shortage meant some organs wasted
And a shortage of coronavirus testing supplies made it difficult for transplant centers to test potential donors who later died of other causes to make sure they were not infected with the virus.
"So there may have been some organ turndowns that we normally wouldn't have seen," says Dr. Chris Freise, a professor and transplant surgeon at UCSF.
As a matter of policy, hospitals canceled virtually all organ transplants from living donors — procedures that involve a family member or someone else donating a kidney or section of their liver.
"That involves bringing two patients into the hospital — the donor and the recipient — and we certainly didn't want to put donors at any significant extra risk," Freise says. "Living-donor kidney transplants ground down to almost a complete halt in most programs across the country."
Some hospitals began doing living donations again in early May, while donations from deceased donors started to increase slowly in mid-April.
That's when Jimenez got her call from Freise's team at UCSF. A condition related to Jimenez's three pregnancies made finding a donor match for her exceptionally difficult, Freise says — "like a needle in a haystack." That also put her at the top of the waiting list in case a match was found.
On April 17, Jimenez's phone rang at 2 a.m. A transplant staffer told her to get to the hospital right away.
"I was excited," Jimenez says. "But then my mind hit me: Somebody died."
All she knows is that the donor was 19 and died in an accident in Los Angeles. Jimenez wrote a letter to the donor's family.
"I told them that I will forever be thinking of them," she says. "I will have him or her in my body for the rest of my life, and I will live for both of us."
Jimenez has six months of recovery ahead of her. She says she's looking forward to going back to work and having more energy to play with her kids.
This story comes from NPR's reporting partnership withKQEDand.
Copyright 2020 KQED. To see more, visit .