Cargill Prayer Dispute Shows Challenges Of Accommodating Increasingly Diverse Workers
The sometimes tense conversation about religious accommodation in the workplace is playing out in rural Colorado.
In Fort Morgan, 150 Muslim workers were fired in late 2015 after a dispute over prayer breaks at a Cargill meat packing plant.
In early 2016 the company changed its rehire policy to allow the fired employees to reapply for their jobs, but some community leaders say the damage has already been done. The city’s east African population, some of whom still have their jobs, are now at odds with those who don't. The relationship between Cargill and the refugee populations it relies on for labor is frayed.
On this particular day, Nurto and Sadiyo Abdi are enjoying a midday cup of spiced tea with milk at their apartment in Fort Morgan. Normally, the twenty-something sisters would be preparing for their afternoon shift at the Cargill plant a short drive down the road.
The sisters are refugees, finding their way to Fort Morgan five years ago, starting their journey in their home country of Somalia. Five times a day the sisters stop to pray, an essential part of their Muslim faith, Nurto says.
Praying at work involves leaving the cutting room floor, changing out of a blood-spattered frock, and returning after five minutes. The timing of the prayer during the plant’s second shift can change with the seasons, and require some flexibility in the plant’s operations to accommodate.
"If I stop my prayer time, everything is hard for me."
“If I stop my prayer time, everything is hard for me,” Nurto said.
After 4 years of work at Cargill, Sadiyo became accustomed to taking these short breaks.
In mid-December the sisters say that changed. A supervisor at Cargill’s beef processing plant told a group of 11 employees they could no longer leave their stations on the meat-cutting line to pray, they say.
"Nobody was ever told that prayer was abolished. Or that prayer could not be accommodated."
“Four times we pray in our homes,” Nurto said. “Only one time [per shift] we pray in Cargill. And they say we don’t have time to go to prayer time.”
Although Cargill disputes this claim, the incident snowballed. The sisters joined with nearly 200 other workers, staying home to protest what they saw as a change in company policy. Until then, they say, they’d been allowed to take a short 5 minute break to pray. After three days of failing to show up, the were fired.
The Council on American-Islamic Relations, which represents some of the fired workers, says the company’s supervisors were sometimes hostile to prayer requests, and that Cargill’s existing religious accommodation policy is vague and ambiguous.
Cargill doesn’t see it that way.
“Nobody was ever told that prayer was abolished. Or that prayer could not be accommodated,” said Mike Martin, a Cargill spokesman.
“There are times, specific times, when because of staffing levels an individual request for prayer may not be granted at a specific time on a specific day,” Martin added.
During the last decade, America’s meatpacking plants have become increasingly diverse, with more immigrants from various cultural and religious backgrounds filling jobs to cut meat. Cargill has attempted to keep up, Martin says, installing reflection rooms for prayer in its facilities and being flexible with break times. Still, cross-cultural misunderstanding and tension seems inevitable.
“It would be hard to go year round without someone misperceiving something,” Martin said. “But this seems to be on a different level.”
Workplace disputes are difficult to discuss in abstract terms, says Rachel Arnow-Richman, director of the University of Denver’s workplace law program. They involve dynamic circumstances, complex relationships and fact-dependent cases. And increasingly in the country’s meat packing facilities shifts are often staffed by a mix of workers who hold strong religious and cultural beliefs.
“The reality is that it’s not always clear what constitutes a reasonable accommodation, or an undue hardship.”
In a large slaughterhouse, for example, one person missing for ten minutes can slow down an entire shift. If a religious accommodation, like a prayer break, imposes a significant cost on the employer, a company has the right to refuse the request, Arnow-Richman said.
"If you don't have your job here, there's not much to stay for."
“The subtleties of what is required or what the employer permits, versus what a supervisor actually does, those can certainly get lost in any workplace, not even accounting for language and cultural differences,” Arnow-Richman said.
In a bid to compromise and give some workers a chance at getting their jobs back, Cargill is allowing the fired employees to reapply sooner than later. But Michaela Holdridge, executive director of One Morgan County, a nonprofit that focuses on diversity in Fort Morgan, said it might be too little too late.
“We already have word of about 20 families or so who have already left,” Holdridge said.
Holdridge said the families are scattering across the Midwest and Great Plains, heading to Wyoming, Nebraska, Minnesota and Ohio to find jobs.
“If you don’t have your job here, there’s not much to stay for,” she added.
With a large number of workers leaving town all at once, Holdridge said a new wave of immigrants with their own religious and cultural traditions could find themselves looking for work in Fort Morgan.