What's A 'Super-Spreading Event'? And Has It Happened With COVID-19? | KUNC

What's A 'Super-Spreading Event'? And Has It Happened With COVID-19?

Feb 19, 2020
Originally published on February 21, 2020 9:46 am

Updated Feb. 21, 11:46 a.m. ET

Last month, a British man went to a conference in Singapore, then on a ski trip to the French Alps.

What he didn't know when he arrived in the Alps was that he was infected with the virus behind the COVID-19 outbreak.

During his stay at a ski village, it appears he infected 11 other people, who subsequently traveled on to the U.K. and Spain, the World Health Organization says.

Early estimates for the new coronavirus suggest that the average infected person spreads the disease to two to three other people. But this man's ski trip caused a cluster of cases.

Some have described this cluster as a "super-spreading event" — in which an individual infects an unusually high number of people. Dr. Mike Ryan, WHO's executive director for health emergencies, said last week that it's way "too early" to call it that — and that officials believe they caught the situation before it ignited a chain that could have spread COVID-19 throughout Europe.

WHO doesn't want to use the term "super-spreader" because it stigmatizes individuals.

These types of cases are a concern to global health researchers because they echo a pattern seen in past epidemics. Super-spreading has triggered explosive chains of transmission in other outbreaks such as SARS, MERS and Ebola.

"The poster child for a super-spreading event happened during the SARS outbreak, where a huge proportion of cases was traced back to the Metropole Hotel," says Jessica Metcalf, a demographer at Princeton University. SARS is the acronym for severe acute respiratory syndrome, a disease also caused by a coronavirus.

Back in 2003, a doctor who had treated SARS patients checked into a room on the 9th floor of the Hong Kong hotel. At least 13 other people on his floor got sick, and when his floormates left the country, they spread the disease to Canada, Vietnam and Singapore. A woman returning to Canada then infected her son, leading to more than 100 new cases in the Toronto hospital where he was treated.

In a 2015 outbreak of Middle East respiratory syndrome in South Korea, about two-thirds of the transmission came from just two super-spreading events in hospitals, which fast-tracked the spread of the virus, says Adam Kucharski, who researches the dynamics of infectious disease at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine.

"In that situation, if you [could have] avoid[ed] those two events happening, you've got rid of most of your outbreak," he says.

In diseases driven by super-spreading, a rule of thumb is the "20/80 rule" — around 20% of individuals are responsible for at least 80% of the infections, though the actual numbers vary by disease, Metcalf says. But a pattern in which outbreaks are driven by relatively few cases holds across several diseases, including HIV, tuberculosis and typhoid, according to researchers who study disease patterns.

There's a lot that's still unknown about what causes super-spreading. Researchers who study it say it's a combination of factors that are hard to disentangle.

Max Lau models infectious disease dynamics at Emory University. From his work on Ebola transmission during the 2014-2015 epidemic in West Africa, he thinks that social behavior plays a big part.

Lau found that super-spreading events tended to happen more around people under 15 or over 45. That could be because "the younger ones or the older ones tend to get more people to visit and care for them when they get sick," he says.

He also thinks biology plays a role. Individuals are more likely to infect others when they're carrying and shedding a lot of virus.

New infections among patients and staff often happen in hospitals, where people go because they're really sick. Their immune systems are weakened, and they can carry a greater volume of the virus than other patients might, making them more infectious. They're also getting hospital procedures that might expose others to their blood or lung fluids.

Both biological and behavioral factors contributed to a 2014 Ebola super-spreading event at a funeral in Sierra Leone. A popular healer treated Ebola patients from an outbreak in neighboring Guinea, contracted the disease and died. Hundreds of mourners came to her funeral and burial.

Bodies of people who recently died can still shed the Ebola virus, says Lau. And in many cultures, including Sierra Leone's, it's traditional for mourners to wash, dress and have direct contact with the body. More than 300 Ebola cases were traced to the healer's funeral, which soon exploded into an outbreak that overwhelmed hospitals in southeastern Sierra Leone.

Another contributor to high transmission events is the local environment, such as stale air in enclosed spaces or a lot of people sharing the same space.

The number of people infected in any situation depends on how the risk factors line up, says David Heymann, an epidemiologist at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine. It's how infectious a person is, what setting they're in, how they behave around others — and whether the people they're interacting with, including health workers, wash their hands frequently and take other measures to protect themselves from infection.

With COVID-19, there have been fewer reports of super-spreading events so far compared with the early days of SARS, says Jamie Lloyd-Smith of the University of California, Los Angeles who studies how diseases spread. But why? "Is it a biological difference between the two viruses?" he says, "Or [have] we actually learned some things about how to deal with these viruses and infection control?"

It's a question that China's Center for Disease Control and Prevention is pondering, based on early conclusions from a new report from this week: "To date, there is no evidence of a super-spreader event occurring in any of the Chinese health facilities serving COVID-19 patients," the report states. "However, we do not know whether this is due to the nature of the virus itself or whether these events have been successfully prevented."

To try to stop super-spreading events, public health officials say it's important to try to find cases early to figure out who else was exposed and to keep sick people away from those who aren't.

These are strategies that date back to the 1800s, but they have worked to contain past epidemics, including SARS in 2004, says WHO. These common-sense strategies are the best way they know to stop a new disease from spreading.

Copyright 2020 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

MARY LOUISE KELLY, HOST:

Super-spreading events. Public health officials tracking the COVID-19 outbreak are on the lookout for them. The new coronavirus is already considered highly contagious. It spread from a single city in China to the rest of the world within 30 days. Super-spreading events in which one person infects many others could make the outbreak spread even faster. NPR's Pien Huang explains why.

PIEN HUANG, BYLINE: Last month, a British man went to a conference in Singapore and then on a ski trip to the French Alps. What he didn't know when he arrived in the Alps was that he was infected with the virus behind the COVID-19 outbreak. And it appears that during his stay at the ski village, he infected 11 other people, the World Health Organization says. Some are calling this a super-spreading event. Max Lau at Emory University models how diseases spread.

MAX LAU: For certain individual, they infect much more persons than the typical average person.

HUANG: Early estimates for the new coronavirus suggest that the average infected person usually only spends it to two or three other people. The possibility of super-spreading events has worried researchers since the new coronavirus was discovered. It's because, in the past, super-spreading events have triggered explosive chains of transmission and other outbreaks. Jessica Metcalf researches population and disease dynamics at Princeton University.

JESSICA METCALF: The poster child for super-spreading events happened during the SARS outbreak, where a huge proportion of cases was traced back to this Metropole Hotel.

HUANG: Back in 2003, there was a doctor treating patients who had SARS, another coronavirus disease. He checked into the Metropole Hotel in Hong Kong. At least 13 other people on his floor got sick. And from that hotel, the disease spread to Canada, Vietnam and Singapore. In 2014, more than 300 new Ebola cases were traced to the funeral of a popular healer who had died of the disease in Sierra Leone.

Adam Kucharski studies the dynamics of infectious diseases at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine. In a 2015 outbreak of another coronavirus in South Korea...

ADAM KUCHARSKI: About two-thirds of the transmission actually came from just two events in hospitals.

HUANG: A businessman infected at least 26 people in one hospital, and a person at a different hospital sickened 82 other patients, visitors and staff. Both of those instances fast-tracked the spread of the virus.

KUCHARSKI: So in that situation, if you can avoid those two events happening, you've got rid of most of your outbreak.

HUANG: So why does super spending happen? Jamie Lloyd-Smith, who studies how diseases spread at UCLA, says the factors that cause it vary a lot.

JAMIE LLOYD-SMITH: It runs the gamut from someone who's feeling perfectly well but happens to be spreading virus without knowing it to someone who's quite sick in the active, trying to help them puts the virus into the air and exposes people.

HUANG: Super-spreading events often happen in hospitals, where very sick people get hospital procedures that might expose others to their blood or their lung fluids. Lloyd-Smith says that, so far, super-spreading events may be happening with the new coronavirus, but they don't seem to be causing explosive outbreaks as they did in the early days of SARS. The question is, why?

LLOYD-SMITH: Is that a biological difference between the two viruses? Or is it a consequence of, you know, we actually learned some things about how to deal with these viruses and infection control?

HUANG: The case of the man that spread the new coronavirus to 11 others in the Alps, health officials believe they caught that situation before it ignited a chain that could have spread COVID-19 throughout Europe. Early detection of any kind of infection is the best way to stop a disease from spreading.

Pien Huang, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.